NAG group canola systems trial

2014

Research organisatons

Trial details

Researcher(s) Martin Harries
Year(s) 2014
Contributor Northern Agri Group
Trial location(s) Site 9, Binnu, WA
NAG group canola systems trial locations
Aims

To test a range of different canola herbicide system types at different row spacings

Key messages

Round-up ready yeilded better that the other two herbicide groups, the varieties tested were all hybrids. TT canola yielded lower than the other two herbcide groups the varieties tested at both narrow and wide rows were OP's Narrow row out yeilded wide rows 1.641 to 1.450 t/ha.

Lead research organisation Department of Agriculture and Food WA
Host research organisation N/A
Related program N/A
Acknowledgments N/A
Other trial partners Not specified
Download the trial report to view additional trial information

Method

Crop type Oilseed: Canola
Treatment type(s)
  • Crop: Type
  • Sowing: Row spacing
Trial type
Trial design
Sow rate or Target density Not specified
Sowing machinery Not specified
Plot size Not specified
Plot replication Not specified
Plot blocking Not specified
Plot randomisation Not specified
Paddock history Not specified
Fertiliser Not specified
Herbicide Not specified
Insecticide Not specified
Fungicide Not specified
Pesticide Not specified
Soil amelioration Not specified
Seed treatment Not specified
Inoculant Not specified
Tillage Not specified
Other trial notes Not specified
Download the trial report to view additional method/treatment information

Trial results Table 1

@T1: at 10% moisture
# Variety
Treatment 1
Treatment 2
Grain yield (t/ha) Moisture (%) Oil (%) Protein (%) Oil (%)
1 43C80 Clearfield 220 1.377 10 37.9 23.6 37.9
2 43C80 Clearfield 220 1.429 9.5 40.4 24.2 40.2
3 43C80 Clearfield 440 1.341 10.1 39.1 26.1 39.1
4 43C80 Clearfield 440 1.33 9.7 42 23.8 41.9
5 43C80 Clearfield 440 1.42 10.8 40.9 23.6 41.3
6 43C80 Clearfield 220 1.455 11 40 23.5 40.4
7 43Y85 Clearfield 220 1.506 10.2 38.5 24.4 38.6
8 43Y85 Clearfield 220 1.26 10.8 37.8 25.9 38.1
9 43Y85 Clearfield 220 1.325 10.8 39.8 24.6 40.2
10 43Y85 Clearfield 440 1.091 9 39.9 24.9 39.5
11 43Y85 Clearfield 440 1.33 9.9 41.7 23.7 41.7
12 44Y87 Clearfield 220 1.403 9.9 39 24.2 39
13 44Y87 Clearfield 220 1.805 11.3 37.9 23.9 38.5
14 44Y87 Clearfield 220 1.688 11.3 38.5 23.9 39.5
15 44Y87 Clearfield 440 1.284 9.8 41 26.4 40.9
16 44Y87 Clearfield 440 1.352 11 38.1 23.9 38.5
17 44Y87 Clearfield 440 1.42 11 41.1 25 41.6
18 Hyola 474 Clearfield 440 1.318 10.5 40.2 26 40.4
19 Hyola 474 Clearfield 440 1.568 8.9 42 23.9 41.5
20 Hyola 474 Clearfield 440 1.614 10.9 40.5 24 40.9
21 Hyola 575 Clearfield 440 1.409 10.7 40.3 24.1 40.6
22 Hyola 575 Clearfield 440 1.341 8.6 41.9 23.6 41.3
23 Hyola 575 Clearfield 440 1.409 11.3 38.8 23.6 39.4
24 Hyola 577 Clearfield 440 0.909 9.7 41.5 25.1 41.4
25 Hyola 577 Clearfield 440 1.239 11.1 39 23.6 39.5
26 Hyola 577 Clearfield 440 1.398 10.9 41.6 24.2 42
27 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 1.795 7.9 42.7 21.7 41.7
28 43Y23 Roundup Ready 220 1.831 10.3 39.3 22.4 39.4
29 43Y23 Roundup Ready 220 1.935 9.4 41.9 10.8 41.6
30 43Y23 Roundup Ready 220 2.091 7.6 46 20.7 44.8
31 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 1.568 9 42 21.3 41.5
32 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 1.841 9.6 41 21.2 40.8
33 44Y24 Roundup Ready 220 1.974 9.8 41.5 22.5 41.4
34 44Y24 Roundup Ready 220 1.896 8.6 42.2 23.4 41.6
35 44Y24 Roundup Ready 220 2.065 10.1 43.5 21.7 43.5
36 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 1.761 9 42.2 22.8 41.7
37 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 1.807 8.5 43.2 22.2 42.5
38 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 1.705 11.8 41.4 21.8 42.2
39 GT41 Roundup Ready 220 1.727 9 42.3 23.5 41.8
40 GT41 Roundup Ready 220 1.74 8.6 43.2 21.4 42.5
41 GT41 Roundup Ready 220 1.883 8.5 44 21.9 43.3
42 GT41 Roundup Ready 440 1.602 8 44 22 43
43 GT41 Roundup Ready 440 1.227 8 43.8 22.4 42.8
44 GT41 Roundup Ready 440 1.739 10.5 45 20.9 45.3
45 GT50 Roundup Ready 220 2.052 9.2 40.3 21.5 39.9
46 GT50 Roundup Ready 220 2.169 9.7 42.3 22.2 42.2
47 GT50 Roundup Ready 220 2.325 9.9 42 21.4 42
48 GT50 Roundup Ready 440 1.818 9.2 43.8 21.7 43.4
49 GT50 Roundup Ready 440 1.614 9.6 42.6 20.7 42.3
50 GT50 Roundup Ready 440 2.136 9.6 42.5 21 42.3
51 Hyola 404 Roundup Ready 440 1.784 7.5 45.6 21.3 44.4
52 Hyola 404 Roundup Ready 440 1.58 7 46.4 21.5 44.9
53 Hyola 404 Roundup Ready 440 1.659 8.7 43.9 20.9 43.3
54 Hyola 500 Roundup Ready 440 1.693 11.1 42.6 21.6 43.1
55 Hyola 500 Roundup Ready 440 1.375 9.4 42.8 20.9 42.5
56 Hyola 500 Roundup Ready 440 1.42 9.4 43 21.2 42.7
57 Hyola 525 Roundup Ready 220 1.506 9 43.6 22.3 43.6
58 Hyola 525 Roundup Ready 220 1.649 7.8 44.9 21.5 43.8
59 Hyola 525 Roundup Ready 220 1.831 9.2 44 22.4 43.6
60 Hyola 525 Roundup Ready 440 0.489 7.9 43.9 22.2 42.9
61 Hyola 525 Roundup Ready 440 0.523 11.6 41.9 21.5 42.6
62 Hyola 525 Roundup Ready 440 1.318 8.8 44.3 21.4 43.7
63 IH30 Roundup Ready 220 1.558 8.7 42.5 21.8 41.9
64 IH30 Roundup Ready 220 1.597 9.7 43.1 21 43
65 IH30 Roundup Ready 220 1.805 8.2 43.1 22.6 42.3
66 IH30 Roundup Ready 440 1.568 8.7 42.7 22.1 42.1
67 IH30 Roundup Ready 440 1.443 8.7 42.9 21.7 42.3
68 IH30 Roundup Ready 440 1.602 9.1 43.2 21.4 42.8
69 IH50 Roundup Ready 220 1.636 11.4 40.4 22.2 41
70 IH50 Roundup Ready 220 1.714 8.9 42.2 22 41.7
71 IH50 Roundup Ready 220 1.831 10.9 40.5 22.9 40.9
72 IH50 Roundup Ready 440 1.205 8 44.6 21.4 43.6
73 IH50 Roundup Ready 440 1.784 10.6 43.5 21 43.8
74 IH50 Roundup Ready 440 1.739 8.7 42.5 21.1 41.9
75 Bonito Triazine Tolerant 220 1.377 9.6 44.7 20.6 44.5
76 Bonito Triazine Tolerant 220 1.597 7.6 45.3 21.2 44.1
77 Bonito Triazine Tolerant 220 1.857 9.7 44.4 20.2 44.3
78 Bonito Triazine Tolerant 440 0.602 8.1 44.7 21.8 43.8
79 Bonito Triazine Tolerant 440 1.364 7.9 45.3 20.9 44.3
80 Bonito Triazine Tolerant 440 1.477 10.8 43.6 20.6 44
81 Hyola 450 Triazine Tolerant 440 1.477 7.5 44.4 22.4 43.2
82 Hyola 450 Triazine Tolerant 440 1.557 10.7 42.9 21.1 43.2
83 Hyola 450 Triazine Tolerant 440 1.682 9.7 43.7 22.3 43.6
84 Hyola 559 Triazine Tolerant 440 0.932 9.9 43.8 21.3 43.8
85 Hyola 559 Triazine Tolerant 440 1.273 8.1 43.7 22.3 42.8
86 Hyola 559 Triazine Tolerant 440 1.08 10.1 43.5 21.6 43.5
87 NT 0252 Triazine Tolerant 220 1.831 9.8 43.4 20.4 43.3
88 NT 0252 Triazine Tolerant 220 1.766 8 45.8 21.9 44.8
89 NT 0252 Triazine Tolerant 220 1.909 10.8 42.1 21.3 42.5
90 NT 0252 Triazine Tolerant 440 1.091 8 45 22.1 44
91 NT 0252 Triazine Tolerant 440 1.386 10.8 42 20.9 42.4
92 NT 0252 Triazine Tolerant 440 1.466 10.4 44.8 20.3 45
93 Snapper Triazine Tolerant 220 1.195 9.8 45 20.6 44.9
94 Snapper Triazine Tolerant 220 1.156 9.7 46.2 20.9 46
95 Snapper Triazine Tolerant 220 1.195 8.8 41.2 22.7 40.7
96 Snapper Triazine Tolerant 440 1.011 9.5 43 21.8 42.8
97 Snapper Triazine Tolerant 440 1.068 8.3 44.9 22.1 44.1
98 Snapper Triazine Tolerant 440 1.057 10 43.8 22.5 43.8
99 Sturt Triazine Tolerant 220 1.104 9.9 44.1 20.1 44.1
100 Sturt Triazine Tolerant 220 1.039 8.5 44.8 21.5 44.1
101 Sturt Triazine Tolerant 220 1.26 9 42.9 21.7 42.4
102 Sturt Triazine Tolerant 440 1 9.8 42.8 22 42.7
103 Sturt Triazine Tolerant 440 1.034 10.5 43.5 20.7 43.7
104 Sturt Triazine Tolerant 440 1 9.9 44 20 44

Grain yield t/ha


Loading

Moisture %


Loading

Oil %


Loading

Protein %


Loading
Observed trial site soil information
Trial site soil testing
Not specified
Soil conditions
Trial site Soil texture
Site 9, Binnu, WA Not specified
Derived trial site soil information
Australian Soil Classification Source
Trial site Soil order
Site 9, Binnu, WA Chromosol
National soil grid Source
NOTE: National Soil Grid data is aggregated information for background information on the wider area
Actual soil values can vary significantly in a small area and the trial soil tests are the most relevant data where available

Soil properties

Loading

Climate

Site 9, Binnu WA 2014


Derived climate information
NOTE: Exact trial site locality unknown - Climate data may not be accurate
Loading
Loading
BOM Data source BINNU [768] 0km proximity to trial site location


Loading

Some data on this site is sourced from the Bureau of Meteorology

SILO weather estimates sourced from https://www.longpaddock.qld.gov.au/silo/
Jeffrey, S.J., Carter, J.O., Moodie, K.B. and Beswick, A.R. (2001). Using spatial interpolation to construct a comprehensive archive of Australian climate data , Environmental Modelling and Software, Vol 16/4, pp 309-330. DOI: 10.1016/S1364-8152(01)00008-1.