NAG group canola systems trial

2014

Research organisatons

Trial details

Researcher(s) Martin Harries
Year(s) 2014
Contributor Northern Agri Group
Trial location(s) Site 15, Binnu, WA
NAG group canola systems trial locations
Aims

To test a range of different canola herbicide system types at different row spacings

Key messages
  • Round-up ready yeilded better that the other two herbicide groups, the varieties tested were all hybrids.
  • TT canola yielded lower than the other two herbcide groups the varieties tested at both narrow and wide rows were OP's Narrow row out yeilded wide rows 1.641 to 1.450 t/ha.
Lead research organisation Department of Agriculture and Food WA
Host research organisation N/A
Related program N/A
Acknowledgments N/A
Other trial partners Not specified
Download the trial report to view additional trial information

Method

Crop type Canola
Treatment type(s)
  • Crop: Type
  • Sowing: Row spacing
  • Variety: Type
Trial type Experimental
Trial design Randomised,Replicated

Binnu 2014

Sow date Not specified
Harvest date Not specified
Plot size Not specified
Plot replication Not specified
Download the trial report to view additional method/treatment information

Download results

Trial results Table 1

@T1: at 10% moisture
# Variety
Treatment 1
Treatment 2
Protein (%) Moisture (%) Oil (%) Grain yield (t/ha) Oil (%)
1 43C80 Clearfield 220 23.6 10 37.9 1.377 37.9
1 43C80 Clearfield 220 24.2 9.5 40.4 1.429 40.2
2 43C80 Clearfield 440 26.1 10.1 39.1 1.341 39.1
2 43C80 Clearfield 440 23.8 9.7 42 1.33 41.9
3 43C80 Clearfield 440 23.6 10.8 40.9 1.42 41.3
3 43C80 Clearfield 220 23.5 11 40 1.455 40.4
4 43C80 Clearfield 220 24.4 10.2 38.5 1.506 38.6
4 43C80 Clearfield 220 25.9 10.8 37.8 1.26 38.1
5 43C80 Clearfield 220 24.6 10.8 39.8 1.325 40.2
5 43C80 Clearfield 440 24.9 9 39.9 1.091 39.5
6 43C80 Clearfield 440 23.7 9.9 41.7 1.33 41.7
6 43C80 Clearfield 220 24.2 9.9 39 1.403 39
7 43Y85 Clearfield 220 23.9 11.3 37.9 1.805 38.5
7 43Y85 Clearfield 220 23.9 11.3 38.5 1.688 39.5
8 43Y85 Clearfield 440 26.4 9.8 41 1.284 40.9
8 43Y85 Clearfield 440 23.9 11 38.1 1.352 38.5
9 43Y85 Clearfield 440 25 11 41.1 1.42 41.6
9 43Y85 Clearfield 440 26 10.5 40.2 1.318 40.4
10 43Y85 Clearfield 440 23.9 8.9 42 1.568 41.5
10 43Y85 Clearfield 440 24 10.9 40.5 1.614 40.9
11 43Y85 Clearfield 440 24.1 10.7 40.3 1.409 40.6
11 43Y85 Clearfield 440 23.6 8.6 41.9 1.341 41.3
12 44Y87 Clearfield 440 23.6 11.3 38.8 1.409 39.4
12 44Y87 Clearfield 440 25.1 9.7 41.5 0.909 41.4
13 44Y87 Clearfield 440 23.6 11.1 39 1.239 39.5
13 44Y87 Clearfield 440 24.2 10.9 41.6 1.398 42
14 44Y87 Roundup Ready 440 21.7 7.9 42.7 1.795 41.7
14 44Y87 Roundup Ready 220 22.4 10.3 39.3 1.831 39.4
15 44Y87 Roundup Ready 220 10.8 9.4 41.9 1.935 41.6
15 44Y87 Roundup Ready 220 20.7 7.6 46 2.091 44.8
16 44Y87 Roundup Ready 440 21.3 9 42 1.568 41.5
16 44Y87 Roundup Ready 440 21.2 9.6 41 1.841 40.8
17 44Y87 Roundup Ready 220 22.5 9.8 41.5 1.974 41.4
17 44Y87 Roundup Ready 220 23.4 8.6 42.2 1.896 41.6
18 Hyola 474 Roundup Ready 220 21.7 10.1 43.5 2.065 43.5
18 Hyola 474 Roundup Ready 440 22.8 9 42.2 1.761 41.7
19 Hyola 474 Roundup Ready 440 22.2 8.5 43.2 1.807 42.5
19 Hyola 474 Roundup Ready 440 21.8 11.8 41.4 1.705 42.2
20 Hyola 474 Roundup Ready 220 23.5 9 42.3 1.727 41.8
20 Hyola 474 Roundup Ready 220 21.4 8.6 43.2 1.74 42.5
21 Hyola 575 Roundup Ready 220 21.9 8.5 44 1.883 43.3
21 Hyola 575 Roundup Ready 440 22 8 44 1.602 43
22 Hyola 575 Roundup Ready 440 22.4 8 43.8 1.227 42.8
22 Hyola 575 Roundup Ready 440 20.9 10.5 45 1.739 45.3
23 Hyola 575 Roundup Ready 220 21.5 9.2 40.3 2.052 39.9
23 Hyola 575 Roundup Ready 220 22.2 9.7 42.3 2.169 42.2
24 Hyola 577 Roundup Ready 220 21.4 9.9 42 2.325 42
24 Hyola 577 Roundup Ready 440 21.7 9.2 43.8 1.818 43.4
25 Hyola 577 Roundup Ready 440 20.7 9.6 42.6 1.614 42.3
25 Hyola 577 Roundup Ready 440 21 9.6 42.5 2.136 42.3
26 Hyola 577 Roundup Ready 440 21.3 7.5 45.6 1.784 44.4
26 Hyola 577 Roundup Ready 440 21.5 7 46.4 1.58 44.9
27 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 20.9 8.7 43.9 1.659 43.3
27 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 21.6 11.1 42.6 1.693 43.1
28 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 20.9 9.4 42.8 1.375 42.5
28 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 21.2 9.4 43 1.42 42.7
29 43Y23 Roundup Ready 220 22.3 9 43.6 1.506 43.6
29 43Y23 Roundup Ready 220 21.5 7.8 44.9 1.649 43.8
30 43Y23 Roundup Ready 220 22.4 9.2 44 1.831 43.6
30 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 22.2 7.9 43.9 0.489 42.9
31 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 21.5 11.6 41.9 0.523 42.6
31 43Y23 Roundup Ready 440 21.4 8.8 44.3 1.318 43.7
32 43Y23 Roundup Ready 220 21.8 8.7 42.5 1.558 41.9
32 43Y23 Roundup Ready 220 21 9.7 43.1 1.597 43
33 44Y24 Roundup Ready 220 22.6 8.2 43.1 1.805 42.3
33 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 22.1 8.7 42.7 1.568 42.1
34 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 21.7 8.7 42.9 1.443 42.3
34 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 21.4 9.1 43.2 1.602 42.8
35 44Y24 Roundup Ready 220 22.2 11.4 40.4 1.636 41
35 44Y24 Roundup Ready 220 22 8.9 42.2 1.714 41.7
36 44Y24 Roundup Ready 220 22.9 10.9 40.5 1.831 40.9
36 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 21.4 8 44.6 1.205 43.6
37 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 21 10.6 43.5 1.784 43.8
37 44Y24 Roundup Ready 440 21.1 8.7 42.5 1.739 41.9
38 44Y24 Triazine Tolerant 220 20.6 9.6 44.7 1.377 44.5
38 44Y24 Triazine Tolerant 220 21.2 7.6 45.3 1.597 44.1
39 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 220 20.2 9.7 44.4 1.857 44.3
39 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 21.8 8.1 44.7 0.602 43.8
40 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 20.9 7.9 45.3 1.364 44.3
40 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 20.6 10.8 43.6 1.477 44
41 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 22.4 7.5 44.4 1.477 43.2
41 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 21.1 10.7 42.9 1.557 43.2
42 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 22.3 9.7 43.7 1.682 43.6
42 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 21.3 9.9 43.8 0.932 43.8
43 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 22.3 8.1 43.7 1.273 42.8
43 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 440 21.6 10.1 43.5 1.08 43.5
44 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 220 20.4 9.8 43.4 1.831 43.3
44 GT41 Triazine Tolerant 220 21.9 8 45.8 1.766 44.8
45 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 220 21.3 10.8 42.1 1.909 42.5
45 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 440 22.1 8 45 1.091 44
46 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 440 20.9 10.8 42 1.386 42.4
46 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 440 20.3 10.4 44.8 1.466 45
47 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 220 20.6 9.8 45 1.195 44.9
47 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 220 20.9 9.7 46.2 1.156 46
48 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 220 22.7 8.8 41.2 1.195 40.7
48 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 440 21.8 9.5 43 1.011 42.8
49 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 440 22.1 8.3 44.9 1.068 44.1
49 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 440 22.5 10 43.8 1.057 43.8
50 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 220 20.1 9.9 44.1 1.104 44.1
50 GT50 Triazine Tolerant 220 21.5 8.5 44.8 1.039 44.1
51 Hyola 404 Triazine Tolerant 220 21.7 9 42.9 1.26 42.4
51 Hyola 404 Triazine Tolerant 440 22 9.8 42.8 1 42.7
52 Hyola 404 Triazine Tolerant 440 20.7 10.5 43.5 1.034 43.7
52 Hyola 404 Triazine Tolerant 440 20 9.9 44 1 44
53 Hyola 404
53 Hyola 404
54 Hyola 500
54 Hyola 500
55 Hyola 500
55 Hyola 500
56 Hyola 500
56 Hyola 500
57 Hyola 525
57 Hyola 525
58 Hyola 525
58 Hyola 525
59 Hyola 525
59 Hyola 525
60 Hyola 525
60 Hyola 525
61 Hyola 525
61 Hyola 525
62 Hyola 525
62 Hyola 525
63 IH30
63 IH30
64 IH30
64 IH30
65 IH30
65 IH30
66 IH30
66 IH30
67 IH30
67 IH30
68 IH30
68 IH30
69 IH50
69 IH50
70 IH50
70 IH50
71 IH50
71 IH50
72 IH50
72 IH50
73 IH50
73 IH50
74 IH50
74 IH50
75 Bonito
75 Bonito
76 Bonito
76 Bonito
77 Bonito
77 Bonito
78 Bonito
78 Bonito
79 Bonito
79 Bonito
80 Bonito
80 Bonito
81 Hyola 450
81 Hyola 450
82 Hyola 450
82 Hyola 450
83 Hyola 450
83 Hyola 450
84 Hyola 559
84 Hyola 559
85 Hyola 559
85 Hyola 559
86 Hyola 559
86 Hyola 559
87 NT 0252
87 NT 0252
88 NT 0252
88 NT 0252
89 NT 0252
89 NT 0252
90 NT 0252
90 NT 0252
91 NT 0252
91 NT 0252
92 NT 0252
92 NT 0252
93 Snapper
93 Snapper
94 Snapper
94 Snapper
95 Snapper
95 Snapper
96 Snapper
96 Snapper
97 Snapper
97 Snapper
98 Snapper
98 Snapper
99 Sturt
99 Sturt
100 Sturt
100 Sturt
101 Sturt
101 Sturt
102 Sturt
102 Sturt
103 Sturt
103 Sturt
104 Sturt
104 Sturt

Grain yield t/ha


Loading

Moisture %


Loading

Oil %


Loading

Protein %


Loading
Observed trial site soil information
Trial site soil testing
Not specified
Soil conditions
Trial site Soil texture
Site 15, Binnu, WA Not specified
Derived trial site soil information
Australian Soil Classification Source: ASRIS
Trial site Soil order
Site 15, Binnu, WA Chromosol
Soil Moisture Source: BOM/ANU
Average amount of water stored in the soil profile during the year, estimated by the OzWALD model-data fusion system.
Year Site 15, Binnu WA
2014 330.6mm
2013 333.3mm
2012 348.2mm
2011 400.9mm
2010 324.7mm
2009 358.5mm
2008 398.8mm
2007 280.7mm
2006 313.7mm
2005 342.3mm
2004 319.6mm
2003 338.0mm
2002 333.0mm
2001 338.8mm
2000 381.7mm
National soil grid Source: CSIRO/TERN
NOTE: National Soil Grid data is aggregated information for background information on the wider area
Actual soil values can vary significantly in a small area and the trial soil tests are the most relevant data where available

Soil properties

Loading

Climate

Derived climate information

No observed climate data available for this trial.
Derived climate data is determined from trial site location and national weather sources.

Site 15, Binnu WA

NOTE: Exact trial site locality unknown - Climate data may not be accurate
Loading
Loading
Loading

Some data on this site is sourced from the Bureau of Meteorology

SILO weather estimates sourced from https://www.longpaddock.qld.gov.au/silo/
Jeffrey, S.J., Carter, J.O., Moodie, K.B. and Beswick, A.R. (2001). Using spatial interpolation to construct a comprehensive archive of Australian climate data , Environmental Modelling and Software, Vol 16/4, pp 309-330. DOI: 10.1016/S1364-8152(01)00008-1.



Trial last modified: 25-06-2019 13:35pm AEST