Regional crown rot management – Garah 2016

2016

Research organisaton
Funding source

Trial details

Aims

Crown rot (CR), caused predominantly by the fungus Fusarium pseudograminearum (Fp),
remains a major constraint to winter cereal production in the northern grains region. Cereal
varieties differ in their resistance to crown rot, which can have a significant impact on their
relative yield in the presence of this disease.
This experiment was one of 11 conducted by NSW DPI in 2016 across central/northern NSW
extending into southern Qld; to examine the impact of crown rot on the yield and quality of
four barley, three durum and 13 bread wheat varieties.

Key messages

Key findings
• Yield loss from crown rot ranged from not significant in the barley varieties SpartacusA and CommanderA
up to around 20% in the barley variety CompassA and bread wheat varieties EGA GregoryA and
LRPB FlankerA.
• Bread wheat variety choice affected yield in the presence of high levels of crown rot infection with five
entries being between 0.32 t/ha to 0.57 t/ha higher yielding than the susceptible bread wheat variety
EGA GregoryA.
• Grain protein levels varied from 11.3% in MitchA up to 14.9% in LRPB SpitfireA. Crown rot infection did not
affect protein levels in any entry.
• Crown rot infection increased the level of screenings in all four barley varieties and the two bread wheat
varieties SunmateA and LRPB ReliantA.

Conclusions:

Cereal crop and variety choice provided a 7–13% yield benefit over growing the susceptible
bread wheat variety EGA GregoryA under high levels of crown rot infection at Garah in 2016.
This could have maximised profit in this growing season, but will not reduce inoculum levels
for subsequent crops because all winter cereal varieties are susceptible to crown rot infection.
Winter cereal crop and variety choice is therefore not the sole solution to crown rot, but rather
just one element of an integrated management strategy to limit losses from this disease.

 

 

Garah NSW 2016

Treatments:

Varieties (20)

• Four barley varieties: CommanderA, CompassA, La TrobeA and SpartacusA.
• Three durum varieties: JandaroiA and LillaroiA plus the numbered line 190873.
• Thirteen bread wheat varieties: EGA GregoryA, LRPB FlankerA, BeckomA, CoolahA,
SunmateA, LRPB LancerA, LRPB ReliantA, LRPB GauntletA, LRPB SpitfireA, MitchA,
SuntopA and SunguardA; (listed in order of increasing resistance to crown rot) plus one
numbered line LPB12-0494.

Lead research organisation Department of Primary Industries NSW
Host research organisation N/A
Trial funding source GRDC DAN00175
Related program N/A
Acknowledgments

This experiment was part of the project National crown rot epidemiology and management
program (DAN00175) with joint investment by NSW DPI and GRDC. Thanks to Andrew and
Bill Yates for providing the trial site and Rick Graham, Jim Perfrement, Mick Dal Santo,
Stephen Morphett (NSW DPI) for sowing, maintaining and harvesting the trial. Thanks to
Chrystal Fensbo (NSW DPI) for grain quality assessments and to Jason Lowien (GrainCorp)
for use of an NIR machine to determine grain protein levels.


Other trial partners Bill and Andrew Yates
Download the trial report to view additional trial information

Method

Crop type Cereal (Grain): Barley
Treatment type(s)
  • Crop: Variety
  • Pest Management
Trial type
Trial design

Garah 2016

Sow date Not specified
Harvest date Not specified
Plot size Not specified
Plot replication Not specified
Fertiliser Not specified
Inoculant Not specified
Other trial notes

TREATMENTS

Varieties (20)

• Four barley varieties: CommanderA, CompassA, La TrobeA and SpartacusA.
• Three durum varieties: JandaroiA and LillaroiA plus the numbered line 190873.
• Thirteen bread wheat varieties: EGA GregoryA, LRPB FlankerA, BeckomA, CoolahA,
SunmateA, LRPB LancerA, LRPB ReliantA, LRPB GauntletA, LRPB SpitfireA, MitchA,
SuntopA and SunguardA; (listed in order of increasing resistance to crown rot) plus one
numbered line LPB12-0494.

RESULTS

Yield

In the no added CR treatment, yield ranged from 3.54 t/ha in the barley variety CommanderA
up to 5.61 t/ha in the bread wheat variety LRPB FlankerA (Table 1).
Only two of the barley varieties, SpartacusA and CommanderA, did not suffer significant yield
loss under high levels of crown rot infection (added CR). In the remaining entries, yield loss
ranged from 7.6% in the bread wheat variety MitchA (0.40 t/ha) up to 21.6% in the barley
variety CompassA (0.93 t/ha).
All four barley varieties, the durum variety DBA LillaroiA and the bread wheat variety
LRPB SpitfireA were lower yielding than EGA GregoryA under high crown rot infection (added
CR). The remaining durum entries and six of the bread wheat varieties (LRPB GauntletA,
SunguardA, LRPB ReliantA, LRPB LancerA, LRPB FlankerA and BeckomA) all produced yields
equivalent to EGA GregoryA in the added CR treatment (Table 1).
The bread wheat entries SunmateA (0.57 t/ha), MitchA (0.49 t/ha), LPB12-0494 (0.36 t/ha),
SuntopA (0.34 t/ha) and CoolahA (0.32 t/ha) were all higher yielding than EGA GregoryA
under high levels of crown rot infection (added CR; Table 1).
Grain quality
Protein levels were relatively high at this site in 2016 and ranged between 11.3% (MitchA) up
to 14.9% (LRPB SpitfireA; Table 1). Crown rot infection (added CR) did not significantly affect
grain protein levels in any of the entries at this site in 2016.
In the no added CR treatment, screening levels ranged from 1.9% in the bread wheat variety
LRPB LancerA up to 7.9% in the barley variety La TrobeA (Table 1).
Screening levels were increased in the added CR treatment, with all four barley varieties and
two of the bread wheat varieties SunmateA and LRPB ReliantA by between 1.7 to 5.6%. In the
remaining entries there was no significant difference in the level of screenings between the no
added CR and added CR treatments. In the added CR treatment, screening levels ranged from
2.9% in the bread wheat variety LRPB LancerA up to 10.7% in the barley variety La TrobeA
 

 

 

Garah 2016

Sow date 10 June 2016
Harvest date 23 November 2016
Plot size Not specified
Plot replication Not specified
Fertiliser

60 kg/ha Urea and 60 kg/ha Granulock 12Z (treated with 400 mL/ha of flutriafol) at sowing

Inoculant Added or no added crown rot at sowing using sterilised durum grain colonised by at least five different isolates of Fp at a rate of 2.0 g/m of row at sowing.
Other trial notes

TREATMENTS

Varieties (20)

• Four barley varieties: CommanderA, CompassA, La TrobeA and SpartacusA.
• Three durum varieties: JandaroiA and LillaroiA plus the numbered line 190873.
• Thirteen bread wheat varieties: EGA GregoryA, LRPB FlankerA, BeckomA, CoolahA,
SunmateA, LRPB LancerA, LRPB ReliantA, LRPB GauntletA, LRPB SpitfireA, MitchA,
SuntopA and SunguardA; (listed in order of increasing resistance to crown rot) plus one
numbered line LPB12-0494.

RESULTS

Yield

In the no added CR treatment, yield ranged from 3.54 t/ha in the barley variety CommanderA
up to 5.61 t/ha in the bread wheat variety LRPB FlankerA (Table 1).
Only two of the barley varieties, SpartacusA and CommanderA, did not suffer significant yield
loss under high levels of crown rot infection (added CR). In the remaining entries, yield loss
ranged from 7.6% in the bread wheat variety MitchA (0.40 t/ha) up to 21.6% in the barley
variety CompassA (0.93 t/ha).
All four barley varieties, the durum variety DBA LillaroiA and the bread wheat variety
LRPB SpitfireA were lower yielding than EGA GregoryA under high crown rot infection (added
CR). The remaining durum entries and six of the bread wheat varieties (LRPB GauntletA,
SunguardA, LRPB ReliantA, LRPB LancerA, LRPB FlankerA and BeckomA) all produced yields
equivalent to EGA GregoryA in the added CR treatment (Table 1).
The bread wheat entries SunmateA (0.57 t/ha), MitchA (0.49 t/ha), LPB12-0494 (0.36 t/ha),
SuntopA (0.34 t/ha) and CoolahA (0.32 t/ha) were all higher yielding than EGA GregoryA
under high levels of crown rot infection (added CR; Table 1).
Grain quality
Protein levels were relatively high at this site in 2016 and ranged between 11.3% (MitchA) up
to 14.9% (LRPB SpitfireA; Table 1). Crown rot infection (added CR) did not significantly affect
grain protein levels in any of the entries at this site in 2016.
In the no added CR treatment, screening levels ranged from 1.9% in the bread wheat variety
LRPB LancerA up to 7.9% in the barley variety La TrobeA (Table 1).
Screening levels were increased in the added CR treatment, with all four barley varieties and
two of the bread wheat varieties SunmateA and LRPB ReliantA by between 1.7 to 5.6%. In the
remaining entries there was no significant difference in the level of screenings between the no
added CR and added CR treatments. In the added CR treatment, screening levels ranged from
2.9% in the bread wheat variety LRPB LancerA up to 10.7% in the barley variety La TrobeA
 

 

 

Download the trial report to view additional method/treatment information

Trial results Table 1

# Variety

Protein %


Loading

Screenings - Added CR %


Loading

Screenings - No added CR %


Loading

Yield - Added CR t/ha


Loading

Yield - No added CR t/ha


Loading
Observed trial site soil information
Trial site soil testing
Site Depth Type pH EC P K N A OC CAT
Garah, NSW 0 - 120cm 167.00
Soil conditions
Trial site Soil texture
Garah, NSW Not specified
Derived trial site soil information
Australian Soil Classification Source: ASRIS
Trial site Soil order
Garah, NSW Vertosol
Soil Moisture Source: BOM/ANU
Average amount of water stored in the soil profile during the year, estimated by the OzWALD model-data fusion system.
Year Garah NSW
2016 257.8mm
2015 250.5mm
2014 238.9mm
2013 227.5mm
2012 254.7mm
2011 257.0mm
2010 282.0mm
2009 278.7mm
2008 293.5mm
2007 309.0mm
2006 310.7mm
2005 327.0mm
2004 385.9mm
2003 443.4mm
2002 464.3mm
2001 479.1mm
2000 578.4mm
National soil grid Source: CSIRO/TERN
NOTE: National Soil Grid data is aggregated information for background information on the wider area
Actual soil values can vary significantly in a small area and the trial soil tests are the most relevant data where available

Soil properties

Loading

Climate

Garah NSW 2016


Observed climate information

Rainfall avg ann (mm) 603mm
Rainfall trial gsr (mm) 174mm

Derived climate information

Garah NSW

NOTE: Exact trial site locality unknown - Climate data may not be accurate
Loading
Loading
Loading

Some data on this site is sourced from the Bureau of Meteorology

SILO weather estimates sourced from https://www.longpaddock.qld.gov.au/silo/
Jeffrey, S.J., Carter, J.O., Moodie, K.B. and Beswick, A.R. (2001). Using spatial interpolation to construct a comprehensive archive of Australian climate data , Environmental Modelling and Software, Vol 16/4, pp 309-330. DOI: 10.1016/S1364-8152(01)00008-1.

Trial report and links

2016 trial report



Trial last modified: 03-10-2019 14:32pm AEST